Modern Childhood

STEP RIGHT UP FOLKS!!!!!!

"Step right up folks! Our unproven, unsubstantiated therapy and treatment is guaranteed to cure all things bothering you about your child. That’s right for the low fee, special offer of $3,499 over the next year, we will cure bedwetting, ADHD, reading disabilities, and just plain child orneriness!!! All you have to do is plunk down your money (special 10% discount if paid in full up front) and bring your child in for treatment – twice a week over the year, and you will see results in all things child. We also have a special deal on this nutria-supplement that we offer at 60% off the retail price ($199) when you sign up for the therapy!!! This nutrio-supplement will get your child to stop bothering you at the dinner table and restaurants. It might even cure sibling rivalry! That’s right folks. Step right up!!!!!!"

It seems that every five years or so there is a hot new treatment on the market that is guaranteed to cure ADHD, dyslexia, behavior issues and other child issues of concern. I have known parents to spend thousands of dollars for an unproven therapy, only to have the child left in the same place he/she was in when the therapy started.

Many of these therapies make no common sense and have little legitimate research support. In addition they often present an indirect approach to address the problem.

Two recent articles article from Great Schools (www.greatschools.orgelaborates on this topic of unproven therapies:

http://www.greatschools.org/LD/managing/controversial-therapies.gs?content=817

http://www.greatschools.org/LD/managing/buyer-beware.gs?content=1022

Be very wary of approaches that are not a close match between your area of concern and what is being targeted in the treatment. Decide what you are targeting and find people experienced in addressing the area of concern.

I tend to think about sports metaphors when explaining this issue and advising parents. If you want to help your child with hitting a baseball, then bring him to a good baseball instructor to work on the skill. If someone told you to have the child swim for a year to become a better baseball player, would that make common sense? Of course not.

Too often approaches offered lack common sense and they are not targeting the area of concern adequately. Yet the person or business trying to sell the program will convince you to part with your money to cure everything.

Be careful before you try and cure all things child!  Don’t be so quick to sign up for the cure!

Tag: Learning disabilities, reading disabilities, child behavior treatments, child therapy

 

 

“Do Your Personal Best All the Time!”

“James must try and do his personal best all the time.”

This was the teacher’s evaluation comment of a child I recently evaluated.

As soon as I read the comment, I felt my blood pressure rise a bit.  I don’t know about you, but I have yet to have a day in my life where I have done my “personal best all the time.”

I think I would settle for a few good hours of my personal best!

Once I started working with James it was  was clear he was not someone who was going to be able to sustain his personal best for more than a brief activity or two.  His issues were the ones often seen with kids who struggle in school.   Low-level writing skills and a weak capacity to sustain his interest for tasks that he saw as too difficult were very clearly a part of his style.

For James, his weaknesses were continually undermining him and his motivation.  He lacked skills that were needed to put forth the sustained effort that the teacher was seeking.  I have been seeing a lot of James-style kids lately.  These kids can’t work through their frustration, have great difficulty putting together a basic paragraph with any coherency, and are pretty disorganized.

I see these kids as having clogged fuel lines for many of the typical classroom activities.

What will unclog them?  It’s hard to say.

I do know that a patient, supportive teacher can work wonders in helping a child become a bit unclogged.  Once the child feels supported, there is often more emotional energy for trying to tackle more difficult tasks.
So, as we start this school year maybe we should watch those statements about, “doing your best all the time. “ Then you might start seeing more bursts of “personal best” throughout the day.

Tags:  Parenting, Struggling children, Learning Disabilities

“Go Up To Your Room and Do Your Work”: The Perils

How many households in America each night hear the refrain, “Go up to your room and start your homework?”

Recognizing that each household is set up differently, it is hard to make generalizations about how and where a child should be doing his or her homework.  For the children of concern, the ones that are easily “lost in the woods ,“  these children have great difficulty functioning independently even in a comfortable and functional work-space that has been set up in their room.

As stated in a previous post, an ongoing concern of yours is to find the “just right” level of parental involvement (http://tinyurl.com/kksvnv).  Recognizing that these children need greater degrees of structuring, cuing and prompting, having a child go off to his room to complete homework may largely be a mistake.

When left to their own devices, think of these kids as free-floating molecules with little to anchor them or bring them back to the task.  Without some level of structure, there is little to help them get started or to keep them on track.

An alternative that provides some anchoring is getting the child in the habit of sitting within relatively close range of a parent, preferably at a dining room table, apart from any action going on in the house.

Ideally, a parent can be sitting close by doing quiet work of their own (e.g., reading, bill paying, etc.)  Just the presence of an adult quietly sitting close by helps to settle things down for the “lost in the woods” type of a child.

It would also be helpful to establish a household “quiet time” where the tone of the house becomes relatively lower than the norm. This may mean shutting off the television and having other children quietly (if they don’t have schoolwork) in a different portion of the house.    (You may need to spend time training the other kids in the house to practice the quiet time so they know what is expected.)

Many families with whom I have worked have found an hour and a half of “quiet time” to be ideal.  Mind you, quiet time does not mean that house has to be “library quiet.”  It’s just that the tone and energy of the house is lower than usual.

Don’t worry if the deckhands (i.e.,  the kids) start whining and protesting.  Stay firm with your establishment of a quiet time and they will soon get used to it.

Establishing this routine as early as possible as the way that homework is done will pay off dividends later.  Many teenagers that I work with are particularly “free-floating” in their room.   They have a very  hard time getting started and seeing tasks through to their conclusion.

It’s never too late to change the routines, but the earlier you create the tone and the routine for homework the better.

Tags:  Parent Involvement, Struggling Learners, Organizational weaknesses, Executive Function Deficits.

——————————————————————-

Not in the South Jersey area? For a free 15 Minute Consultation, contact Dr. Selznick: email – contact@shutdownlearner.com.

To receive free newsletter and updates, go to: www.shutdownlearner.com.

Categories

Latest Posts

Archive